New website by Stoa. Not the official South Dakota Historical Society Press website.

South Dakota Historical Society Press Pierre, South Dakota
Cover of South Dakota History, volume 52 number 3

South Dakota History, Volume 52, Number 3

Volume 52, Number 3 · 2 articles

The latest issue of “South Dakota History,” the quarterly journal of the South Dakota State Historical Society, showcases a unique document from the South Dakota State Archives: the travel journal of Earl Neller, who led a group of children on a one-of-a-kind tour of South Dakota during the height of the Great Depression.

In the summer of 1933, Neller, a teacher from St. Louis, Missouri, took six children—he and his wife Lydia’s two daughters and one son as well as the son and daughters of a family friend—on a hitchhiking adventure from Sioux Falls, South Dakota, to Hebron, North Dakota. After Lydia Neller made plans to visit her parents in Hebron, Earl thought it would be instructive for the children to tramp their way across the Dakotas.

Between June 21 and July 17, when they finally reached Hebron, the travelers visited an array of towns, nature areas, and tourist attractions. At a stop in Mitchell, they saw the Corn Palace. During an extended tour of the Black Hills, they ventured to Mount Rushmore, Iron Mountain Road, Battle Mountain Sanitarium, Harney Peak, Wind Cave, Crystal Cave, Mount Moriah Cemetery, and the Homestake Mine. In addition to walking, they rode a train through the White River Badlands and caught several rides from kind strangers.

Author Matthew Reitzel, who has served as the manuscript/photo archivist with the State Archives program of the South Dakota State Historical Society for seventeen years, reconstructs and contextualizes this group’s unique journey. Alongside colorful excerpts from the travel journal, Reitzel offers insight into the social context of the time. The article includes several photographs taken by Earl Neller as well as contemporary images from the South Dakota State Archives that help bring the story to life. The final product should be of interest to both general readers and scholars of travel and tourism in the region.

$10.00

In This Issue

  1. “We were tramps along with the rest of them”: The Journal of Earl Neller, Who Hitchhiked across South Dakota with Six Children in 1933

    by Matthew T. Reitzel

    At the height of the Great Depression in the summer of 1933, Earl Neller and six children tramped, hitchhiked, and railroaded some 850 miles across the Dakotas over twenty-seven days. Neller, a high school teacher from St. Louis, Missouri, and the children, ages eight to thirteen, hiked west from Sioux Falls, South Dakota, journeyed through the Black Hills, then headed north until they reached their destination in Hebron, North Dakota.

  2. DAKOTA IMAGES | Alvin F. McDonald

    Alvin Frank McDonald was the self-styled “chief guide” at Wind Cave, near Hot Springs, South Dakota, during its early years of operation as a tourist attraction. McDonald was born in Franklin County, Iowa, on 3 April 1873. In 1890, the South Dakota Mining Company tasked his father, Jesse D. McDonald, with overseeing its newly purchased claims to the cave site. Sixteen-year-old McDonald and his brother Elmer soon became dedicated spelunkers. For the next three years, McDonald spent up to nine hours per day methodically exploring the cave system―one of the largest and most labyrinthine in the world―by candlelight. Like the mythical Greek hero Theseus, he unrolled string to mark his path and avoid becoming lost. He kept a meticulous journal that contained precise, invaluable maps of Wind Cave’s rooms and passageways, and eventually explored, named, and mapped ten miles of the subterranean structure. He even wrote that he could not stand to be away from the cave for more than a few days. In 1892, Hot Springs local John Stabler joined the McDonalds to form the Wonderful Wind Cave Improvement Company. Their efforts included an advertising campaign, enlarging certain passageways with explosives to improve accessibility, building a hotel near the site, and establishing a stage to transport visitors for tours―often led by Alvin. Yet the group’s success ignited bitter litigation over the cave’s ownership between Jesse McDonald, Stabler, the South Dakota Mining Company, and assayer Peter Folsom. In summer 1893, McDonald journeyed to Chicago to bring samples from the cave to the World’s Columbian Exposition, where he likely contracted typhoid fever. McDonald died of the disease at the age of twenty on 15 December 1893. President Theodore Roosevelt designated Wind Cave the seventh national park in 1903, effectively ending the ownership dispute. While political patronage, neglect, and limited visitation contributed to the chronic maladministration of Wind Cave for the next few decades, today the park preserves one of the most spectacular cave systems in the United States, along with the surrounding mixed-grass prairie. Alvin McDonald’s grave and memorial is only a short walk from the natural entrance to the cave he loved so dearly.