Donna Agnew

Jamie Wolters From: Sent: To: Subject:

Donna Agnew <donnaagnew49@gmail.com> Wednesday, January 7, 2026 3:38 PM Jamie Wolters STR # 240076

You don't often get email from donnaagnew49@gmail.com. Learn why this is important

Caution: This email originated from outside of the organization. DO NOT click on links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

Hello, Today I contacted Grayson to renew the STR permit and learned that STR permits are filed annually and must be renewed at least 30 days in advance. This was my first notice of this requirement. While I own the Corporate Entity listed on the application, I am the primary individual responsible for the day-to-day management and regulatory compliance of the property. I did not receive notice of the ordinance amendments or the approved STR permit that I paid for and, therefore, did not have the opportunity to timely respond or take the required actions. Both my email and phone numbers are on the application. Given the lack of direct notice to the individual actively managing the property, we respectfully request that this be considered a procedural deficiency and that the matter be waived or granted retroactive relief. We are eager to promptly cure any issue, pay the now annual fee, and move the application forward without further delay. Thank you for your continued review and consideration. I look forward to your final determination. Best regards, Donna Agnew 847-644-3413

Jamie Wolters From: Sent: To: Cc: Subject:

David Isljamovski <disljamovski@gmail.com> Thursday, January 8, 2026 12:37 PM Jamie Wolters Chad DuPont Thank you!

Caution: This email originated from outside of the organization. DO NOT click on links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe.

Hi Jamie, Could you please forward the following below to Council, Ryan and Grayson? Thank you! ______________________________________________________________ Dear City Council Members, City Manager, and Director of Zoning, Thank you for taking the time to listen to us and thoughtfully consider our amendment. We truly appreciate your openness, professionalism, discussion, and the effort each of you put into understanding our perspective. We are especially grateful for the grace and amnesty that will be extended. That consideration means a great deal to us, and we do not take it lightly. Your approach demonstrated fairness and a genuine willingness to work collaboratively with residents and owners. Please know that we are more than willing to assist moving forward. If helpful, we would be glad to volunteer our time to share insights, experiences, and practical feedback related to short-term rentals, with the goal of helping develop clear, efficient, and streamlined procedures. We would welcome the opportunity to contribute in any way that supports thoughtful and workable solutions for the community. Thank you again for your time, leadership, and consideration. With sincere appreciation,

David + Chad 1

-David Isljamovski (616) 298-4851 www.lakeshorerealtor.com

To help protect y our priv acy , Micro so ft Office prev nted auto matic download of this pictu re from the In ternet.

1/8/26, 2:44 PM

Comparative Market Analysis

Yearly Market Comparison Comparing Entire MLS As of Thursday, January 8, 2026 2:42:06 PM Search Parameters: Property type Residential; Area of 'Holland/Saugatuck'; Municipality of 'Douglas Vllg'. Number of Sold Listings

Dollar Volume of Sold Listings

2024 2025 Diff

Chg

2024

2025

Diff

Chg

2024

Median Sale Price 2025

Diff

Chg

$ 554,500

-365,500

-39.8%

460,000

554,500

94,500

20.5%

$ 0 -2,578,000 -100.0%

640,000

January

-50.0%

$ 920,000

February

-4 -100.0%

$ 2,578,000

March

0.0%

$ 2,284,800

$ 2,009,000

-275,800

-12.1%

399,900

599,000 199,100

49.8%

April

4 200.0%

$ 1,574,999

$ 2,993,749 1,418,750

90.0%

787,499

495,499 -292,000

-37.1%

May

0.0%

$ 1,890,480

$ 2,677,600

787,120

41.6%

665,000

975,600 310,600

46.7%

June

-75.0%

$ 2,559,000

$ 1,046,000 -1,513,000

-59.2%

630,000 1,046,000 416,000

July

4 400.0%

$ 1,075,000

$ 2,460,000 1,385,000 128.8% 1,075,000

485,000 -590,000

-54.9%

August

25.0%

$ 3,595,000

$ 3,091,000

-504,000

-14.1%

940,000

605,000 -335,000

-35.6%

September

-22.2%

$ 5,326,500

$ 4,137,000 -1,189,500

-22.4%

467,500

500,000

32,500

October

12 300.0%

$ 2,203,000 $ 11,353,000 9,150,000 415.3%

544,000

555,000

11,000

2.0%

November

75.0%

$ 3,689,000

$ 4,101,900

412,900

11.1%

784,500

425,000 -359,500

-45.8%

$ 2,621,000

0 -640,000 -100.0%

66.0%

7.0%

December

-60.0%

$ 1,355,000 -1,266,000

-48.4%

432,000

677,500 245,500

56.8%

Total

24.4% $ 30,316,779 $ 35,778,749 5,461,970

18.0%

515,000

545,000

5.8%

2024

30,000

Number of New Listings

Dollar Volume of New Listings

2024 2025 Diff

Chg

2024

2025

Diff

Chg

541,000

31.4%

15.0% 1,192,500 599,000 -593,500 -49.8%

January

February March

Median List Price 2025

Diff

Chg

50.0%

$ 1,718,900

$ 2,259,900

50.0%

$ 2,385,000

$ 2,744,000

359,000

62.5%

$ 6,595,999

$ 8,969,899

2,373,900

April

4 133.3%

$ 2,252,000

$ 5,612,567

3,360,567 149.2%

May

-1 -14.3%

$ 4,911,800

$ 5,633,000

June

5 166.7%

$ 2,476,900

$ 6,068,400

July

0.0%

$ 7,934,000

August

-1 -11.1%

$ 7,789,799

$ 5,222,895 -2,566,904 -33.0%

739,000 667,450

-71,550

September

75.0%

$ 2,592,900

$ 5,610,400

3,017,500 116.3%

519,000 525,000

6,000

1.2%

October

6 150.0%

$ 3,198,000

$ 6,288,900

3,090,900

96.6%

632,000 597,450

-34,550

-5.5%

November

-3 -50.0%

$ 2,922,800

$ 1,790,000 -1,132,800 -38.8%

494,000 425,000

-69,000 -14.0%

December

3 300.0%

$ 549,000

$ 1,979,800

549,000 374,950 -174,050 -31.7%

Total

721,200

35.9%

859,450 634,900 -224,550 -26.1% 764,000 599,000 -165,000 -21.6% 659,000 700,000

41,000

6.2%

14.6%

474,900 991,500 516,600 108.8%

3,591,500 144.9%

947,000 582,000 -365,000 -38.5%

$ 5,795,100 -2,138,900 -27.0%

965,000 610,000 -355,000 -36.8%

1,430,800 260.6%

39.7% $ 45,327,098 $ 57,974,861 12,647,763

27.9%

636,950 599,000

-37,950

-9.7%

-6.0%

Information is deemed to be reliable, but is not guaranteed. See copyright notice.

https://ric.flexmls.com

1/1